With Roofman, a true story that’s too crazy to believe based on the logline alone, Derek Cianfrance leaves meditative tear-jerker territory to tackle an unbelievable story that’s outrageous only conceptually, but still executed with patience — and a lot of charisma from its actors. Channing Tatum plays real-life robber Jeffrey Manchester with a deeply terrible set of decision-making skills. Tatum is physically comedic yet also gives the role more depth than many of his other characters in the tonally lighter films we’re used to from him lately. That said, despite the film’s awareness of the craziness of his actions, it also stops to reflect on the consequences of those actions on others and his own sense of acceptance within the new life he’s adapted into. Kirsten Dunst is also very layered in her performance and shares great chemistry with Tatum, and Peter Dinklage is a scene-stealing highlight, too.

Roofman is an entertaining time throughout that accomplishes exactly the mission it sets out to do while wisely refraining from becoming an all-out comedy and letting us sit with the characters and their circumstances. Best of all, it may also make you want to research more about the real story behind the movie — and wish for more great leading roles for Tatum like it.