The Safdies’ bold filmmaking style has reinvented storytelling since they entered the scene in their expert use of handheld camerawork and overlapping dialogue to build tension, and Josh Safdie’s newest film is not only his grandest, but also one of the year’s must-watch movies that subverts most modern categorizations. If you had trouble rooting for Adam Sandler’s lead in Uncut Gems, Timothee Chalamet’s portrayal of Marty Mauser is almost as slimy, smooth-talking, and utterly self-centered. Not to mention, it’s the best performance of his entire career, devoting so much physicality in every moment to a character who desires to not only be great, but to be celebrated for his greatness. That’s exactly what causes him to make choices that are hot-headed, self-destructive, and often awful to others. Chalamet is loud but oddly charismatic, energetic, and layered. So why, through it all, are we secretly hoping for our unlikable protagonist to get what he wants, even if we know he might just squander it? Marty hustles, lies, insults, and risks it all to reach his ultimate goal of being the best ping pong player in the world, and Safdie’s direction as certain scenarios open rabbit holes of crazy and unwanted situations captures the exhilarating and hysterical chaos of it all.

Odessa A’zion delivers a spectacular breakout performance, giving her character of Rachel a kinetic unpredictability and standing out as a pivotal role in the story that’s impossible to look away from. Gwyneth Paltrow gives much heft to her character, a lost and washed-up but passionate actress looking to be heard in what she feels is a stuck situation in her life, and Kevin O’Leary also shines in a role defined by authority, vanity, and a coldness that looks down on Marty as he approaches him. Tyler, the Creator also stands out as a friend of Marty’s who shares some of the craziest scenes of the film with him. Safdie does an outstanding job of capturing the dirty and rugged look of 1950s New York, with madness increasing as characters yell over each other with the camera up in their faces, or sometimes bad or desperate situations escalate to much, much worse. The script, camerawork, and editing are working together in unison in every moment to create an intense and nail-biting flow that never stops. Not to mention, Daniel Lopatin’s booming score and the brilliantly selected soundtrack enhance every moment in which they’re present.

Chalamet’s performance that vivdly brings the titular character to life is just as fascinating as trying to piece together the greater poetry of the story. The magnitude of Marty’s ambitions are underscored by his entitlement to his gifts and destiny, and his willingness to deceive and toss those close to him aside. This make it fun to predict whether or not he’ll find the success he’s looking for; if he does, at what cost? And if he doesn’t, which of his egregious mistakes will be his downfall? In expected Safdie fashion, it’s overwhelming direction and sound design contribute to a nail-biting watch that resonates as a wickedly structured character study, an absurdly shocking comedy, and one of the one of the most epic dramas of the year.